The U.S. Department of Agriculture’s (USDA) Food and Nutrition Service (FNS) released a proposed rule to reform the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP) expanded eligibility pathway, known as Broad-Base Categorical Eligibility (BBCE). Published on Tuesday, November 10, the rule would require households that qualify for SNAP through Temporary Assistance for Needy Families (TANF) to receive actual assistance, which would mostly mean cash aid. Comments are due December 10, 2026.

The categorical eligibility pathway was originally written so that beneficiaries of Aid to Families with Dependent Children (AFDC) and Supplemental Security Income (SSI) would not need to resubmit their information to enroll in SNAP. Before 1996, the statutory income limits for AFDC generally aligned with the SNAP program, so the pathway made sense. However, when the 1996 welfare reform transformed AFDC into TANF, it made the program more work-focused and created budget sustainability, but it also gave states flexibility with the program’s eligibility—creating a delta between state TANF eligibility thresholds and SNAP’s federal statutory threshold.

In 2009, the Obama-administration explicitly permitted a loophole that manipulates this mismatch. In a guidance, USDA redefined TANF “benefits” to include token services like online pamphlets or 1-800 numbers. These cost the states next to nothing to produce, so they could be readily available without impacting state budgets. In doing so, USDA allowed states to use this extensive definition of benefits to bypass SNAP’s statutory eligibility tests. 

There are three statutory limits that matter for SNAP eligibility, and all are impacted by the BBCE loophole. 

  1. Asset Limit: The first is widely known as the asset limit, which is $3,000 or $4,750 for households with a member over 60 years of age or older or with a disability. Federal law does not call it an asset test but as allowable financial resources and limiting resources that are in excess of those allowable amounts. Thus, it is really an excess asset limit. It doesn’t include the household’s home, most retirement and pension plans, and most vehicles.
  2. Gross Income Limit: SNAP households without members who are elderly or with disabilities must meet a 130% Federal Poverty Level (FPL) gross income limit test. 
  1. Net Income Limit: The net income limit test cannot exceed 100% of FPL, which is gross income minus allowable deductions like the cost of housing, child care, etc. Under BBCE, states can circumvent the asset limit, even eliminating it altogether; move the gross income limit up to 200% FPL; or ignore the net income tax.

Of the 41 states that use the Obama-era BBCE definition, 35 set gross limits above the statutory 130%, and 37 eliminate the excess asset limit altogether and one state (Arkansas) only eliminates it for some households. The District of Columbia both ignores the excess asset limit and exceeds the 130% of FPL gross income limit. The proposed rule estimates that when the rule would go into effect in 2029, it would impact around 6.3 million people, or 17.6% of participants, who receive SNAP benefits despite having income or assets above the statutory limits.

Because states check fewer data sources of BBCE households, the existing BBCE definition has been linked to higher state errors. In 2012, GAO found BBCE led to higher payment errors, finding a 17.2% error rate in BBCE households as compared to 6.7% in other households. The Alliance for Opportunity has called for Congress to reform BBCE to help states gain a better handle on their improper payment rates. 

Some states have opted into the BBCE loophole to extend SNAP benefits and address benefit cliffs. However, the current BBCE loophole doesn’t fix cliffs. That’s because higher benefit amounts created by the 2021 Thrifty Food Plan and broader deductions have led to steeper SNAP benefit cliffs. While states may use the BBCE loophole to set a higher gross income limit, the net income limit still applies, leading to a benefit loss when households reach that limit. Erik Randolph of the Georgia Center for Opportunity, a founding A4O partner, has found that households without an elderly or disabled member would need a substantial pay raise to offset the benefit loss. A better solution is to taper SNAP benefits immediately with earned income so that they phase out by the net income limit. 

For nearly two decades, BBCE’s expanded definition of “benefits” has been bad policy that circumvents congressional intent that created eligibility limits in the first place. Skirting the statute has inflated enrollment, led to higher improper payment rates, and doesn’t fix the anti-work impact of benefit cliffs. USDA is right to revise this policy to ensure that its regulation matches the law.